
Widespread Circassian Opposition to Russia’s Propaganda Initiative in Moscow
10/11/26, 09:00
The propaganda stage that Russia sought to set in Moscow with the participation of Circassian organisations met with widespread opposition from clear-minded Circassians who know their history and stand by their past. Following the meeting on 28 October 2026, 44 Circassian and Caucasian diaspora organisations issued a joint statement. Additionally, separate statements came from Türkiye, Syria and Jordan.

The reason for the growing reaction through comments, articles and videos on social media was clear. Russia had presented to the world, with the participation of Circassian organisations, a historical narrative that left out the genocide and exile. Those who attended the meeting, meanwhile, had been unable to explain what concrete right they had secured for Circassians in return. (Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Joint statement by 44 organisations, Statement by the Ankara Circassian Association).
What Did the Participation of Circassian Organisations Give Russia
The meeting was jointly organised by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Rossotrudnichestvo, the institution that carries out Russia’s cultural and cooperation activities abroad, and the International Circassian Association (ICA). Officials and members from the Federation of Caucasian Associations (KAFFED) in Türkiye, the Circassian charitable associations in Jordan and Syria, the Circassia Association in the Israeli settlement of Kfar Kama, the Federation of European Circassian Associations, and various Adyghe Khase organisations in the North Caucasus attended the meeting. As one of the organisations that arranged the meeting, the ICA bears direct responsibility. (Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, KAFFED’s first statement)
The Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced the meeting under the title “Hand in Hand with Russia Through the Centuries, with Glory and Honour.” It linked the event to the “470th anniversary of Kabardino-Balkaria’s accession to the Russian Federation.”
The organisations that signed the joint statement rejected this interpretation of history. Relations established in a limited area in 1557 cannot be presented as the voluntary accession of all Circassians to Russia. Such a narrative keeps the long resistance against the Russian Empire, the Circassian Genocide and forced exile out of sight. Yet it is this exile that explains the existence of Circassian communities living in different countries today. Russia used the presence of the organisations attending the meeting to support a story of togetherness that leaves out this past. (Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Joint statement by 44 organisations).
KAFFED Saw the Problem and Attended Anyway
According to KAFFED’s statement, the initial invitation from the Russian Embassy in June concerned visits to historical and cultural sites in the North Caucasus. The federation consulted regional coordinators to select the people who would join the trip. Moscow was added to the programme later. KAFFED stated that it learned the title of the meeting one day before the trip and found it objectionable. It said it had conveyed this concern to the ICA leadership. The Ankara Circassian Association, however, stated that the meeting had been attended without informing most member associations or seeking their views. (KAFFED’s second statement, Statement by the Ankara Circassian Association)
KAFFED’s responsibility in this process is evident from its own statement. Its leadership had found the title of the meeting objectionable. Nevertheless, it attended. It confined itself to conveying its concern to the ICA. In its first public statement after the meeting, it shared neither the meeting’s title nor its own objection. It presented the gathering as a “historic meeting.” (KAFFED’s first statement, KAFFED’s second statement)
What Was Said About the Genocide and Exile
KAFFED reported that at the meeting it had requested that return be facilitated, that the Circassian language be protected, that scholarships be resumed and that relations with the homeland be developed. Yet neither of its two statements contains a single indication that it raised the genocide and mass exile with Russian officials. While Russia presented Circassian history as centuries of voluntary togetherness, how did KAFFED challenge this narrative? Did it request recognition of the genocide? Did it demand redress for the consequences of exile? The texts published by the federation do not answer these questions. (KAFFED’s first statement, KAFFED’s second statement)
Speaking of return to the homeland requires asking about the obstacles faced by people who return. What request was conveyed on behalf of Circassians whose citizenship or residence permits had been revoked, or who had been denied entry to the country? When protection of the Circassian language was requested, what guarantee was sought for its teaching in schools? KAFFED did not explain these matters. By contrast, it was recorded that the federation’s president had requested that Russia consider Circassians in the diaspora “compatriots.” It was not stated which obstacle this request would remove or which right it would secure. The Istanbul Caucasian Cultural Association also objected to this approach, stressing that return to Circassia is a historical right. (KAFFED’s first statement, Statement by the Istanbul Caucasian Cultural Association, Statement by ÇerkesFed)
The message Russia drew from the meeting, meanwhile, was clear. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs wrote that the Circassian participants had expressed gratitude for the importance Russia attaches to language and culture. It did not specify who had spoken in this way. KAFFED stated that its own speakers had not used the expression “gratitude” and that the thanks concerned the organisation of the meeting. It also said that the subject of the 470th anniversary had not been discussed at the meeting. While Russia used the meeting as propaganda material, KAFFED’s presentation of the event as a “historic meeting” is seen as an attempt to deceive the Circassian diaspora. Russia presented Circassian organisations from different countries as though they supported its own narrative. Those who attended were then compelled to issue statements defending themselves after messages of criticism and condemnation from the diaspora. (Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, KAFFED’s second statement)
Opposition Grew Across Different Countries
In its statement dated 10 November, the Council of Circassian Tribes in Syria strongly condemned the meeting, the way it was organised and its political purpose. It stated that the meeting could not reflect the free will of the Circassian people. It declared that the statements published, the positions taken and the images used after the meeting could not be presented on behalf of Circassians in Syria. It stressed that no individual or organisation could relinquish the Circassian people’s right to determine their own future. (Statement by the Council of Circassian Tribes in Syria)
The Council stated that the narratives of “voluntary accession in 1557” and “centuries of shared history” distorted history. It said that these narratives denied the genocide and exile, portrayed occupation positively and presented the victimised people as though they had consented to their own catastrophe. It regarded participation in such a meeting, silence in the face of this narrative or presenting it positively as disrespect towards Circassian history and the people’s struggle. It stated that recognition of the genocide, return, and language and identity rights could not be brushed aside through folklore events, introductory visits and limited scholarships. The Council also met with participants from the Circassian Charitable Association in Syria on 6 November. This meeting addressed the difference between the programme described in the invitation and the positions that emerged after the meeting. (Statement by the Council of Circassian Tribes in Syria)
A separate Arabic statement issued from Jordan questioned the authority of those who went to Moscow to speak on behalf of Circassians in Jordan. Those who issued the statement found the statement dated 9 November from the leadership of the Circassian Charitable Association in Jordan inadequate. They called on those who attended the meeting to answer the public’s questions at the association (Statement by the Free Circassian People in Jordan).
In Türkiye, the Ankara Circassian Association objected to the failure to consult member associations and to the meeting’s historical framework. The Eskişehir North Caucasian Association stated that Russia was trying to draw the diaspora into its own political discourse. ÇerkesFed demanded legal guarantees for language and cultural rights and asked the participating organisations what concrete result they had obtained. These statements were joined by objections from many individuals on social media. The reaction was not confined to a disagreement among a few organisations. Circassians from different countries made it clear that those who went to Moscow could not speak on behalf of the entire people. (Statement by the Eskişehir North Caucasian Association, Statement by ÇerkesFed, Joint statement by 44 organisations)
Why Was Success Declared Without Any Concrete Gain
The published statements contain no decision facilitating return, no commitment guaranteeing Circassian-language education and no joint timetable for following up on the demands. Russia, meanwhile, made the meeting part of its 470th-anniversary narrative and spread the impression that Circassians were grateful to it. Thus, while the propaganda material Russia had obtained was evident, it remained unclear which right Circassians had gained. (Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, KAFFED’s second statement).
The KAFFED leadership sat down at the table under a title it found objectionable. It could not demonstrate that it had consulted its members about the programme. It did not explain that it had raised the genocide and exile. It could not show that it had obtained a concrete right or guarantee. Nevertheless, it declared the meeting “historic.” This conduct is seen as the excessive presentation of an ill-considered decision to participate as a success. The announced results do not show that the visit provided Circassians with any concrete benefit. By contrast, the visit served to publicise Russia’s distortion of history through the participation of Circassian organisations. The opposition that rose from the diaspora challenged the recording of this irresponsibility as the Circassian people’s approval. (KAFFED’s first statement, KAFFED’s second statement, Announcement by the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs).
As ICPC, we consider defending the history, rights and dignity of the Circassian people our fundamental responsibility. We find it unacceptable for individuals and institutions that establish relations with Russia to participate in Russia’s propaganda activities without raising our people’s fundamental problems, and to present this participation as a success. No individual or institution has the right, through irresponsible decisions, to create the impression that the Circassian people have forgotten the genocide and exile or have adopted Russia’s official historical narrative. Those who conduct these contacts must explain the consequences of their decisions and be accountable to our people.
